Politicians Are Poody Heads

and they're not the only ones…

Leonie Haimson: Can You Trust Computers to Grade Student Writing?

on May 8, 2016

Computerized scoring. Sure, that’s the ticket. Not.
It’s one thing for computers to score “fill in the bubble” multiple choice tests. But essays?
I think not. The program’s seem to be “counting words” and scoring high for excess verbiage.
Somehow, I’m betting that Ernest Hemingway would not have done well on one of these computer-scored tests.

Diane Ravitch's blog

Leonie Haimson, parent activist, worked with a group of other concerned critics to review the explosion of computer-massessment, in particular, the scoring of writing.

“On April 5, 2016, the Parent Coalition for Student Privacy, Parents Across America, Network for Public Education, FairTest and many state and local parent groups sent a letter to the Education Commissioners in the states using the federally funded Common Core tests known as PARCC and SBAC, asking about the scoring of these exams.

“We asked them the following questions:

“What percentage of the ELA exams in our state are being scored by machines this year, and how many of these exams will then be re-scored by a human being?

“What happens if the machine score varies significantly from the score given by the human being?
“Will parents have the opportunity to learn whether their children’s ELA exam was scored by a human being or…

View original post 316 more words

2 responses to “Leonie Haimson: Can You Trust Computers to Grade Student Writing?

  1. PiedType says:

    I know it takes more precious time and personal attention for our educators to read and assess student writing. But that writing may well be the best way to assess a student’s thought processes, grasp of the language, ability to express and logically support ideas, etc.

    At the rate we’re going, I wouldn’t be surprised if the next “innovation” in education is computers (robots?) replacing human teachers in the classroom. It would ensure the uniformity in education that everyone seems to think we need. But why bother with classrooms at all? Why maintain physical school buildings? Just put our entire educational system online and let the kids learn from home. Who needs schools?

    • Zorba says:

      Oh, they’re already trying to implement more and more computers replacing teachers in the K-12 public classrooms, as well as “online learning,” and I don’t mean at the college level (it certainly happens there, but these are adults who can choose to go online or not).
      If you have a chance, you should read some of the articles on Diane Ravitch’s blog. https://dianeravitch.net
      What is happening in our public schools should alarm everyone.

Comments are closed.
The Reality-Based Community

and they're not the only ones...

The Last Of The Millenniums

Just because it always has been, doesn't mean it always will be

Bear with me...

A baby bear finds his way in an all too human world

Mashed Potato Bulletin

Grappling with the mish-mash of American politics


a little mixed up

Social Justice For All

Working towards global equity and equality


frightfully wondrous things happen here.

Bearly Holding On

Some days I have to laugh to keep from destroying the world

Embattled Farmers

Political commentary from an insider

how the hell did i end up here?

The musings of a storyteller by eleanor lois tomczyk

Stonekettle Station

and they're not the only ones...

You're already screwed

& it's your own damn fault


and they're not the only ones...

The Stars Hollow Gazette

and they're not the only ones...

Articles and Investigations - ProPublica

and they're not the only ones...


and they're not the only ones...

Latest articles from Crooks and Liars

and they're not the only ones...

MoJo Blogs and Articles | Mother Jones

and they're not the only ones...

Mock Paper Scissors

The Internet's Band of Incorrigible Spitballers® and Cult Failure Since 2006

Juanita Jean's

and they're not the only ones...

She's A Maineiac

just another plaid-wearin' java-sippin' girl


More than just another wiseass

Empty Nest, Full Life

Formerly: PostDepartumDepression Thoughts about the "post Mommy" years of life

A Mind is a Terrible Thing

and they're not the only ones...

%d bloggers like this: