
The usual headline for this story is: “Marine given dishonorable discharge for criticizing Obama”. Unfortunately for those who are interested in the truth, that’s not actually the story. In fact, not much in that sentence is correct. Yes, Sgt. Gary Stein, is a Marine and will probably be discharged (it hasn’t happened yet). But the discharge won’t be classified as dishonorable. Although it’s called “other-than-honorable”, that’s because there are several classes of discharge (for reasons relating to medical, personal emergencies, etc) of which only one is called “honorable”. [There are five general classes of discharge: Honorable; General (under honorable conditions); Under Other than Honorable Conditions (UOTHC); Bad Conduct; and Dishonorable. The first three are given when a service member is administratively discharged, while the latter two are the outcome of the judicial process.]
Also, the discharge isn’t for criticizing Obama. What happened was Sgt. Stein wrote on his Facebook page that he wasn’t going to follow all the orders he might receive from the President. Because the President is in charge of the military, that’s the sort of thing that cannot be allowed. For one thing, it’s against the rules all service personnel agree to when they sign up. Since Stein had been in the service for 10 years, he had to know about that.
Personally, I think the military over-reacted. When called on it, Sgt. Stein changed the posting and apologized for writing it. In a case like that I think that perhaps a reduction in rank (and pay grade) would be sufficient punishment and still show other military people that the folks in charge won’t put up with that sort of crap. But they didn’t ask me and what’s done is done. Of course there’s going to be considerable backlash from the conservative members of the armed forces, to say nothing of the screaming the civilians will do, but with any luck the bozos who made this decision won’t learn anything from it. After all, once a poody head…well, you know.
Sources: UPI, MSNBC